Compare materials at a glance
This table compares ten material and format routes used in food packaging. It can help you see which ones merit a closer look for your product. The right choice still depends on the finished pack, the packing process and the market. Check the linked detail pages and current source documents before relying on a market claim.
On a narrow screen, scroll the comparison sideways to see every column.
| Material family | Common formats | Strengths | Watchouts | Recyclability / EPR | Typical applications to assess |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mono-PE | Bags, pouches, vacuum bags, lidding | Wide sealing window. Broadest US film recycling collection (Store Drop-off). | Lower oxygen barrier than laminates without coatings. | APR Preferred >90% PE. Oregon 2026: 43 c/lb. | Frozen, dry goods, snacks, retail meat with coating. |
| Mono-PP | Flow wrap, VFFS, lidding, pouches | Heat tolerance. Stiffness. Better moisture barrier than mono-PE. | Tighter sealing window. PP collection less developed in NA. | APR Preferred >90% PP per ISO 19069. Oregon 2026: 102 c/lb (no PP-stream credit yet). | Snack flow wrap, hot-fill, microwaveable. |
| PA/PE nylon | Vacuum chamber pouches, thermoform bottom web | High oxygen barrier. Puncture resistance. Deep-draw thermoformability. | Multi-material. Recyclability rules differ by jurisdiction. | APR: requires testing. German Minimum Standard: certified recyclable since 2022. | Fresh and processed meat primals, hard cheese. |
| OPP/CPP | Flow wrap, VFFS, pre-made pouches | Same polymer family on both layers. Can qualify as mono-PP. | Metallisation, PET or added barrier layers can change eligibility; check the complete structure against current criteria. | Mono-PP qualifying when within APR / Canada GDR 6 limits. | Snacks, confectionery, baked goods flow wrap. |
| PET-based flexible | Lidding outer, pouch outer, laminate print layer | Print quality, stiffness, dimensional stability. | Disqualifying material in PE / PP film streams. | Non-recyclable in flexible streams unless PET-on-PET designs. | Lidding films, premium pouch outers. |
| EVOH barrier | Thin coextruded layer in PE or PP structures | Excellent oxygen barrier at low gauge. | Different polymer family. Tight caps on permitted percentage. | APR Preferred up to 10 wt% in mono-PE; 6 wt% in mono-PP, with maleated tie layers. | High-barrier flexible structures within mono-material rules. |
| Paper-based | Folding cartons, paper bags, paper pouches, paperboard trays | Fiber-based construction and established paper collection routes for eligible packs. | Coatings can disqualify from paper recycling. Thermal and moisture limits. | Acceptable in paper streams when coating compatible. Oregon 2026 polycoated paperboard: 48 c/lb. | Dry goods, takeaway, paper-based ready-meal trays. |
| PET/PE lidding | Top web for tray-seal MAP and thermoform-lidding | Stiffness. Heat tolerance. Clean PE-to-tray seal. | Multi-material. No clean recycling path with traditional design. | Oregon 2026 plastic laminate: 102 c/lb. Alternative lidding constructions require separate, pack-specific assessment. | Retail MAP fresh meat, poultry, fish, ready meals on PET / CPET trays. |
| PET / CPET / PP trays | Pre-formed trays for retail MAP, ready meals, salads | Stiffness and formability. CPET ovenable. APET clear. | Tray and lidding system must be matched to preserve recycling route. | Oregon 2026: PET thermoformed 57 c/lb. PP tubs/pails 19 c/lb. | Fresh meat, poultry, ready meals, dairy, baked goods. |
| Aluminium trays | Foil containers, ovenable trays | High thermal performance. Metal collection may be available, subject to local rules and pack condition. | Higher unit cost. Brittle to dimpling. | Oregon 2026: aluminium containers 6.0 c/lb (lowest fee tier). | Ovenable ready meals, retort, premium positioning. |
The recyclability and EPR entries depend on the complete pack, the jurisdiction, the scheme and the date. The figures shown here are examples from named schedules, not a fee quote for your product. Check the current rules and the finished-pack evidence before making a claim or filing.